Another Slice of Cake in Baltimore: A Neighborhood Bakery Focused on Layer Cakes and Custom Orders

Another Slice of Cake is a small-format bakery in Canton specializing in made-to-order layer cakes, cupcakes, and dessert boxes, operating with advance-order workflow rather than walk-in display cases.

What Another Slice of Cake actually is

Located on O'Donnell Street in Canton, Another Slice of Cake operates as a custom-order bakery with limited walk-in availability. The business centers on tiered cakes for celebrations, with flavor combinations that rotate seasonally. Rather than stock shelves with pre-made items, the owner works from a small production kitchen and takes orders primarily through phone and email, with a pickup model. This structure means no impulse purchases, but also no stale inventory and consistent freshness for customers ordering ahead.

Services, menu, and pricing

Custom layer cakes begin at $35 for a single-layer four-inch cake and scale to $85 and above for three-tier celebration cakes, depending on flavor and filling complexity. Cupcakes are available in half-dozen and dozen orders, typically $3 to $4 per cupcake. Flavor options have included red velvet, chocolate bourbon, lemon lavender, and salted caramel, though the menu shifts with seasons. Fillings and frostings can be customized; cream cheese, Swiss meringue, and chocolate ganache are standard options. Prices vary with custom requests; contact directly for quotes on specialty designs or larger orders. Most cakes require 48 to 72 hours notice, though rush orders may be accommodated depending on schedule.

How Another Slice of Cake compares to other Baltimore bakeries

Charm City Cakes on Fleet Street operates as a full-service bakery with a retail storefront, larger production capacity, and walk-in accessibility; it suits customers seeking immediate purchases or who want to see finished cakes in person. Artifact Bakery in Fells Point focuses on European-style pastries and bread rather than custom cakes, serving coffee-shop traffic throughout the day. Delacious Bakery in Harbor East offers both cake orders and a built-out café with seating. Another Slice of Cake's advantage lies in price point and flexibility: ordering directly with the baker allows for detailed customization at lower cost than large-format operations, and the advance-order model means no premium for rush turnaround. Choose Another Slice of Cake if you have time to plan ahead and want direct communication with the baker about flavor preferences or dietary needs; choose Charm City Cakes if you need the cake within hours or prefer browsing finished designs on display.

Who it suits and who it does not suit

This bakery works well for office celebrations, intimate dinner parties, wedding rehearsal dinners, and customers with specific flavor requests or dietary restrictions who want to discuss options directly. The advance-order requirement and limited walk-in hours mean it does not serve last-minute needs or browsers. Customers uncomfortable ordering sight-unseen or without visual portfolio reference may prefer competitors with storefront displays. Those seeking gluten-free or vegan cakes should confirm availability when calling, as the menu accommodates special diets but does not advertise them as standard.

What the first visit involves

Call or email to describe the occasion, preferred flavors, and desired size. The owner will discuss options, confirm pricing, and take a 50 percent deposit to secure the order. No in-person consultation is required for straightforward requests; complex designs may warrant a call or photo exchange. Pick up occurs on the scheduled date, typically during posted business hours. The cake arrives in a sturdy box with basic plating guidance if it requires assembly or simple decoration at home.

Hours, parking, and logistics

Another Slice of Cake operates by appointment and limited walk-in hours; specifics change seasonally. Confirm current hours and the phone number or email address for orders before visiting. Street parking is available on O'Donnell Street in Canton, typical for the neighborhood. The location is a 10-minute walk from Canton waterfront attractions, making it accessible before or after exploring the area.

Another Slice of Cake fills a specific niche in Baltimore's dessert landscape: affordable, made-fresh, directly customizable layer cakes for planners willing to order ahead. For celebrations where flavor and flexibility matter more than impulse convenience, it delivers consistent quality at transparent pricing.