Love Me Two Times in Baltimore: A Consignment Shop Built on Repeat Customer Trust

Love Me Two Times is a women's consignment boutique in Baltimore's Federal Hill neighborhood that specializes in gently used contemporary clothing, with an inventory model built around seasonal rotation and repeat sellers rather than bulk volume.

What Love Me Two Times actually is

The shop operates as a selective consignment operation, accepting clothing on a case-by-case basis rather than offering drop-off consignment to anyone who walks in. The owner curates inventory by building relationships with regular consigners and purchasing outright from occasional sellers, which keeps the stock tighter and more intentional than typical consignment chains. The store occupies roughly 800 square feet and holds between 400 and 600 pieces at any given time, heavily weighted toward women's contemporary brands from the past three to five years. The selection skews toward everyday wear—jeans, sweaters, blazers, dresses—rather than formal evening wear or vintage costume pieces.

Services, consignment terms, and pricing

Consignors are vetted before items are accepted. The shop takes pieces on a 60-40 split, with consigners receiving 40 percent of the sale price. Consigned items remain on the floor for 90 days; unsold pieces are either returned to the consignor or, with prior agreement, donated to local nonprofits. A consignor can expect to move items priced between $15 and $60, depending on brand and condition. High-end contemporary labels like Madewell, Everlane, and Equipment typically price at the upper end. Fast-fashion pieces or those showing wear price between $8 and $20.

Walk-in customers buy direct from the floor. Prices for buyer-ready inventory average $12 to $45 per item, with occasional higher-ticket pieces. The shop does not negotiate on price. Consignors must call or email ahead to schedule drop-off; the owner typically reviews submissions within two weeks.

How it compares to other Baltimore consignment options

The Consignment Gallery in Canton and Play It Again Sports' women's clothing section both operate on higher-volume, lower-curation models and accept walk-in consignments. Both stock a wider price range and inventory depth, which suits shoppers seeking size or style quantity. Love Me Two Times trades breadth for editorial choice; the inventory reflects what the owner believes works, not what she can fit on racks. Crossroads Trading, a chain with a Baltimore presence, accepts consignments on the spot but operates at a faster turnover pace and carries a younger-skewing, trend-focused assortment. Love Me Two Times appeals to shoppers hunting for specific contemporary basics or building a capsule wardrobe, rather than those browsing for surprise finds or trend pieces.

Who it suits and who it does not suit

This shop works well for consigners with 10 or more quality pieces per season who want selective placement rather than the certainty of immediate acceptance at every consignment store. Buyers seeking specific contemporary brands in good condition, or those building a second-hand wardrobe intentionally, find the curation useful. The narrow size range on any given day can frustrate shoppers looking for extended size runs. Those seeking high-end designer labels, vintage, or formal wear should look elsewhere.

What a first visit involves

Browsers enter directly to the sales floor without appointment. Items are organized by category (tops, bottoms, dresses, outerwear) and by size within each section. A consignor calling ahead can expect a 10-to-15-minute in-person review of items, followed by a phone call or email with acceptance decisions. Accepted items receive a consignment agreement covering the 90-day period and payment terms.

Hours, parking, and logistics

The shop operates Tuesday through Saturday, 11 a.m. to 5 p.m., with limited Sunday hours (verify current schedule by phone, as weekend hours shift seasonally). Street parking is available along Light Street and in nearby Federal Hill lots; metered parking costs $2 per hour. The location sits one block from the Cross Street Market, allowing combined shopping trips. Public transit via the Orange Light Rail Line stops three blocks north.

Love Me Two Times fills a specific need in Baltimore's secondhand retail landscape by refusing to separate curation from volume, which means consigners and buyers both benefit from the owner's eye rather than her storage space.